| Sport | Year | Name | Event |
|
Track and Field Men/Women |
|||
| 1975 | David Hill | 110 m hurdles | |
| 1978 | George Itz* | 1500 m | |
| 1982 | Keith Coughlin | 10,000 m | |
| 1982 | Michelle Lussier | Heptathalon | |
| 1982 | Lisa Warren | Heptathalon | |
| 1982 | Christy Baker | 3000 m | |
| 1983 | Carol McCleod | Javelin | |
| 1983 | Cathy Carnes | 5000 m | |
| 1984 | Diane Weeder* | 3000 m | |
| 1984 | Diane Weeder | 1500 m | |
| 1984 | Cathy Carnes | 5000 m | |
| 1984 | Carol McCleod | Javelin | |
| 1984 | Amos DeLuz | Javelin | |
| 1985 | James White | 5000 m (Indoor) | |
| 1985 | James White* | 10,000 m | |
| 1985 | Cathy Dors | Javelin | |
| 1985 | Rich Volkman | Hammer | |
| 1985 | Carol McCleod | Javelin | |
| 1986 | James White | 5000 m (Indoor) | |
| 1986 | James White* | 10,000 m | |
| 1986 | Stephan Baptista | Hammer | |
| 1986 | Cathy Dors | Javelin | |
| 1987 | Stephan Baptista* | Hammer | |
| 1988 | David Araujo | Long Jump (Indoor) | |
| 1988 | David Araujo | Long Jump | |
| 1988 | David Araujo | Triple Jump | |
| 1991 | Kathleen Fitzgibbons | Javelin | |
| 1992 | Eric Lopes | 110 m Hurdles | |
| 1996 | Keith Rose | Javelin | |
| 1997 | Keith Rose | Javelin | |
| 1998 | Gary Mello | 5000 m | |
| 2005 | Jonathan Garcia | 55 m Hurdles (Indoor) | |
| 2005 | Jonathan Garcia | 110 m Hurdles | |
| 2005 | Bruce Zapasnik | Javelin | |
| 2006 | Jonathan Garcia* | 55 m Hurdles (Indoor) | |
| 2006 | Jonathan Garcia | 110 m Hurdles | |
| 2007 | Jonathan Garcia* | 110 m Hurdles | |
| 2008 | Jonathan Garcia* | 55 m Hurdles (Indoor) |
|
| 2012 | Phito Gondre | 60 m Dash (Indoor) | |
| 2012 | Chris Perry | Long Jump (Indoor) | |
| 2013 | Adam Jones | High Jump (Indoor) | |
| 2013 | Krista Chauvin | Hammer (Outdoors) | |
| 2014 | Kevin Cutler | High Jump (Indoors) | |
| 2015 | Kevin Cutler | High Jump (Outdoors) | |
| 2016 | Kevin Cutler | High Jump (Indoors) | |
| Cross Country, Men | 1975 | Peter Smith | |
| 1980 | Brian Lockard | ||
| 1981 | Keith Coughlin | ||
| 1982 | Bob Cosgrove | ||
| 1984 | James White | ||
| 1985 | James White* | ||
| 1985 | Helder Braz | ||
| 1994 | Deon Barrett | ||
| 2003 | Abdulgani Abdi | ||
| Cross Country, Women | 1981 | Cathy Carnes | |
| 1982 | Cathy Carnes | ||
| 1982 | Diane Weeder | ||
| 1983 | Diane Weeder | ||
| 1983 | Donna Weeder | ||
| 1985 | Nicole Fogarty | ||
| Baseball | 1975 | Joe Jason | |
| 1978 | Dermot Moriarity | ||
| 1980 | Mark Chicoine | ||
| 1988 | Rod Correira | ||
| 1991 | John Graham | ||
| 1992 | John Graham | ||
| 1998 | Pat Schultz | ||
| 2015 | Cory DeMedeiros | ABCA (2nd) & D3Baseball.com (3rd) | |
| Field Hockey | 1988 | Nancy Boucher-Quintin | |
| 1990 | Temple Mitchell | ||
| 1991 | Temple Mitchell | ||
| 2006 | Robin Dziedzic | ||
| 2007 | Robin Dziedzic | ||
| Basketball, Men | 1989 | Kevin Kolek | |
| 1991 | Waldemar Sender | ||
| 1992 | Steve Haynes | ||
| 1993 | Steve Haynes | ||
| 2008 | Dan Holbrook | ||
| 2015 | Jordan Rezendes | ||
| 2016 | Jordan Rezendes | ||
| Basketball, Women | None | ||
| Equestrian | 2015 | Sarah Kieran |
IHSA (Open) |
| Football | 1998 | Michael Cotton |
|
| 2016 | Pat Sullivan |
||
| Golf | 1977 | David Downing* | |
| 1977 | Bob Hickham | ||
| 1977 | Bob Silvia | ||
| Ice Hockey | 2005 | Eric Frank | |
| 2006 | Jon Dryjowicz-Burek | ||
| Lacrosse, Men | None | ||
| Lacosse, Women | 2004 | Katelyn Elliott |
Women's Lacrosse.com All-American Rookie Team |
| Soccer, Men | None | ||
| Soccer, Women | 1994 | Rachel Barbarossa | |
| Softball | None | ||
| Swimming/Diving, Men | 1990 | Tom Egan | 1-meter Dive |
| 1990 | Tom Egan | 3-meter Dive | |
| 1991 | Tom Egan | 1-meter Dive | |
| 1991 | Tom Egan | 3-meter Dive | |
| 1992 | Tom Egan* | 1-meter Dive | |
| 1992 | Tom Egan* | 3-meter Dive | |
| 1996 | Michael Lane | 100 Breast | |
| 1996 | Michael Lane | 200 Breast | |
| 1997 | Michael Lane | 100 Breast | |
| 1997 | Michael Lane | 200 Breast | |
| Swimming/Diving, Women | 1980 | Sandra McCloskey | 200 Free |
| 1981 | Sandra McCloskey | 200 Free | |
| 1982 | Laurel Dodge | 50 Back | |
| 1982 | Kathleen Dite | 50 Fly | |
| 1983 | Laurel Dodge | 50 Back | |
| 1983 | Katleen Dite | 50 Fly | |
| 1993 | Kirsten (Watters) Modestow | 200 Free | |
| 1994 | Kirsten (Watters) Modestow | 200 Free | |
| Tennis, Men | None | ||
| Tennis, Women | None | ||
| Volleyball | None | ||
Top All-America Award Winners
| Name | A-A Awards | Sport(s) | All-America Year/Event |
| James White |
6 |
Track and Field/Cross Country |
1984 Cross Country |
| 1985 Cross Country National Champion | |||
| 1985 5,000 meters Indoors | |||
| 1985 10,000 meters Outdoors | |||
| 1986 5,000 meters Indoors | |||
| 1986 10,000 meters Outdoors National Champion | |||
| Tom Egan |
6 |
Diving |
1990 1-meter diving |
| 1990 3-meter diving | |||
| 1991 1-meter diving | |||
| 1991 3-meter diving | |||
| 1992 1-meter diving National Champion | |||
| 1992 3-meter diving National Champion | |||
| Jon Garcia |
6 |
Track and Field |
2005 55-meter hurdles Indoor |
| 2005 110-meter hurdles Outdoor | |||
| 2006 55-meter hurdles Indoors National Champion | |||
| 2006 110-meter hurdles Outdoors | |||
| 2007 110-meter hurdles Outdoors National Champion | |||
| 2008 55-meter hurdles Indoors National Champion | |||
| Diane Weeder |
4 |
Track and Field/Cross Country |
1982 Cross Country |
| 1983 Cross Counrty | |||
| 1984 3,000-meters Outdoors National Champion | |||
| 1984 1,500-meters Outdoors | |||
| Cathy Carnes |
4 |
Cross Country/Track and Field | 1981 Cross Country |
| 1982 Cross Country | |||
| 1983 5,000-meters Outdoors | |||
| 1984 5,000-meters Outdoors | |||
| Michael Lane |
4 |
Swimming |
1996 100 Breast |
| 1996 200 Breast | |||
| 1997 100 Breast | |||
| 1997 200 Breast |
UMass Dartmouth National Champions
| Name | Year | Event | |
| 1. | David Downing | 1977 | Golf |
| 2. | George Itz | 1978 | Track and Field 1,500 meters Outdoors |
| 3. | Diane Weeder | 1984 | Track and Field 3,000 meters Outdoors |
| 4. | James White | 1985 | Cross Country |
| 5. | James White | 1986 | Track and Field 10,000 meters Outdoors |
| 6. | Stephan Baptista | 1987 | Track and Field Hammer |
| 7. | Tom Egan | 1992 | 1-Meter Diving |
| 8. | Tom Egan | 1992 | 3-Meter Diving |
| 9. | Jon Garcia | 2006 | Track and Field 55-meter hurdles Indoors |
| 10. | Jon Garcia | 2007 | Track and Field 110-meter hurdles Outdoors |
| 11. | Jon Garcia | 2008 | Track and Field 55-meter hurdles Indoors |